Kuonetsetsa Chitetezo cha Odwala: Njira Yachipatala mu Chipatala cha Chiropractic
Kodi akatswiri azachipatala ku chipatala cha chiropractic amapereka bwanji njira yachipatala kuti apewe zolakwika zachipatala kwa anthu omwe ali ndi ululu?
Introduction
Zolakwa zachipatala zinachititsa kuti 44,000-98,000 amwalira m'chipatala ku America chaka chilichonse, ndipo zina zambiri zinayambitsa kuvulala koopsa. (Kohn et al., 2000) Chiwerengerochi chinali choposa chiwerengero cha anthu amene amamwalira chaka chilichonse ndi AIDS, khansa ya m’mawere, ndi ngozi za galimoto panthawiyo. Malinga ndi kafukufuku wamtsogolo, chiwerengero chenicheni cha imfa chikhoza kukhala pafupi ndi 400,000, ndikuyika zolakwika zachipatala monga chifukwa chachitatu cha imfa ku US. Kaŵirikaŵiri, zolakwa zimenezi sizichokera kwa akatswiri azachipatala amene ali oipa mwachibadwa; m'malo mwake, ndizo zotsatira za zochitika zadongosolo ndi kayendetsedwe ka zaumoyo, monga machitidwe osagwirizana ndi opereka chithandizo, ma network a inshuwaransi osagwirizana, kusagwiritsidwa ntchito bwino kapena kusowa kwa ndondomeko za chitetezo, ndi chisamaliro chosagwirizana. Nkhani ya lero ikuyang'ana njira yachipatala yopewera cholakwika chachipatala muzochitika zachipatala. Timakambirana zachipatala chogwirizana ndi chithandizo chamankhwala chothandizira anthu omwe akudwala matenda aakulu. Timawatsogoleranso odwala athu powalola kuti afunse mafunso ofunika kwambiri komanso ovuta kwa omwe amawathandiza. Dr. Alex Jimenez, DC, amangogwiritsa ntchito chidziwitsochi ngati ntchito yophunzitsa. chandalama
Kufotokozera Zolakwa Zachipatala
Kuzindikira cholakwika chachipatala chomwe chili gawo lofunikira kwambiri pazokambirana zilizonse zokhudzana ndi kupewa zolakwika zachipatala. Mutha kuganiza kuti iyi ndi ntchito yosavuta, koma izi ndizotheka mpaka mutayang'ana pamitundu yambiri ya mawu omwe amagwiritsidwa ntchito. Mawu ambiri amagwiritsidwa ntchito mofanana (nthawi zina molakwika) popeza mawu ena amatha kusinthasintha, ndipo nthawi zina, tanthauzo la liwu limadalira zapadera zomwe zikukambidwa.
Ngakhale kuti bungwe la zaumoyo linanena kuti chitetezo cha odwala ndi kuthetsa kapena kuchepetsa zolakwika zachipatala zinali zofunika kwambiri, Grober ndi Bohnen adanena posachedwa monga 2005 kuti adalephera m'dera limodzi lofunika kwambiri: kudziwa tanthauzo la "mwinamwake funso lofunika kwambiri ... vuto lachipatala? Kulakwa kwachipatala ndiko kulephera kukwaniritsa zomwe munakonza pachipatala. (Grober & Bohnen, 2005) Komabe, palibe mawu alionse amene munthu angawatchule kuti ali ndi vuto lachipatala—odwala, chithandizo chamankhwala, kapena china chilichonse—amene akufotokozedwa m’nkhaniyi. Ngakhale zili choncho, tanthauzoli limapereka chikhazikitso cholimba cha chitukuko china. Monga mukuwonera, tanthauzo lenilenili lili ndi magawo awiri:
- Kulakwitsa: Kulephera kukwaniritsa zomwe unakonzeratu monga momwe unafunira.
- Vuto lokonzekera: ndi njira yomwe, ngakhale ndi kuphedwa mwangwiro, sikutulutsa zotsatira zomwe mukufuna.
Lingaliro la zolakwika za kuphedwa ndi kukonza zolakwika sizokwanira ngati tikufuna kufotokozera zolakwika zachipatala mokwanira. Izi zikhoza kuchitika kulikonse, osati kuchipatala kokha. Chigawo cha kayendetsedwe kachipatala chiyenera kuwonjezeredwa. Izi zimabweretsa lingaliro la zochitika zosasangalatsa, zotchedwa zochitika zoyipa. Tanthauzo lodziwika bwino la chochitika choyipa ndi kuvulaza mwadzidzidzi odwala omwe amabwera ndi chithandizo chamankhwala m'malo mwa matenda awo. Tanthauzoli lapeza kuvomerezedwa padziko lonse lapansi mwanjira ina. Mwachitsanzo, ku Australia, mawu akuti zochitika amatanthauzidwa ngati kuvulaza komwe kunapangitsa munthu kulandira chithandizo chamankhwala. Izi zikuphatikizapo matenda, kugwa koyambitsa kuvulala, ndi nkhani za mankhwala operekedwa ndi dokotala ndi zipangizo zachipatala. Zochitika zina zosavomerezeka zitha kupewedwa.
Mitundu Yodziwika ya Zolakwa Zachipatala
Nkhani yokhayo ndi lingaliro ili ndikuti sizinthu zonse zoipa zomwe zimachitika mwangozi kapena mwadala. Chifukwa wodwalayo amatha kupindula, zomwe zimayembekezeredwa koma zolekerera zimatha kuchitika. Pa mankhwala a chemotherapy, nseru ndi kutayika tsitsi ndi zitsanzo ziwiri. Pamenepa, kukana chithandizo chomwe akulangizidwacho chingakhale njira yokhayo yanzeru yopewera zotsatirapo zosasangalatsazo. Timafika pamalingaliro azovuta zomwe zingapewedwe komanso zosalephereka pamene tikukonzanso tanthauzo lathu. Sikophweka kuyika chisankho chololera kukhudzika kumodzi zikadziwika kuti zotsatira zabwino zidzachitika nthawi imodzi. Koma cholinga chokha sichinthu chowiringula. (Patient Safety Network, 2016, para.3) Chitsanzo china cha cholakwika chokonzekera chingakhale kudulidwa kwa phazi lamanja chifukwa cha chotupa ku dzanja lamanzere, chomwe chikanakhala kuvomereza chochitika chodziwika bwino ndi chonenedweratu poyembekezera zotsatira zopindulitsa pamene palibe chomwe chinayamba. Palibe umboni wotsimikizira kuyembekezera zotsatira zabwino.
Zolakwa zachipatala zomwe zimavulaza wodwala ndizo zomwe timayang'ana kwambiri pa kafukufuku wathu. Komabe, zolakwa zachipatala zimatha ndipo zimachitika ngati wodwala sanavulazidwe. Kupezeka kwa zophonya pafupi kungapereke chidziwitso chamtengo wapatali pokonzekera momwe mungachepetsere zolakwika zachipatala m'chipatala. Komabe, kuchuluka kwa zochitikazi poyerekeza ndi zomwe madokotala amawauza pafupipafupi kuyenera kufufuzidwa. Kuphonya kwapafupi ndi zolakwika zachipatala zomwe zikanavulaza koma sizinachitike kwa wodwalayo, ngakhale wodwalayo akuchita bwino. (Martinez et al., 2017) N’chifukwa chiyani mungavomereze chinachake chimene chingakubweretsereni mlandu? Taganizirani zimene zinachitika pamene namwino, pazifukwa zilizonse, anali atangoyang'ana zithunzi za mankhwala osiyanasiyana ndipo anali pafupi kupereka mankhwala. Mwinamwake chinachake sichim'kumbukira, ndipo amasankha kuti si momwe mankhwala enieni amawonekera. Atayang'ana, adapeza kuti mankhwala olakwika adaperekedwa. Akaona mapepala onse, amakonza zolakwikazo n’kupatsa wodwalayo malangizo oyenerera. Kodi zingatheke kupeŵa cholakwika m'tsogolomu ngati zolemba zoyang'anira zikuphatikizapo zithunzi za mankhwala oyenera? N'zosavuta kuiwala kuti panali kulakwitsa ndi mwayi wovulaza. Mfundo imeneyi imakhalabe yoona mosasamala kanthu kuti tinali ndi mwayi woipeza m’nthawi yake kapena kuvutika ndi zotsatirapo zilizonse zoipa.
Zolakwika za Zotsatira & Njira
Timafunikira deta yathunthu kuti tipeze njira zothetsera chitetezo cha odwala komanso kuchepetsa zolakwika zachipatala. Pang'ono ndi pang'ono, pamene wodwalayo ali m'chipatala, zonse zomwe zingatheke kuti zisawonongeke ndikuziika pangozi ziyenera kufotokozedwa. Madokotala ambiri atsimikiza kuti kugwiritsa ntchito mawu olakwika ndi zochitika zowawa kunali kokwanira komanso koyenera pambuyo poyang'ana zolakwika ndi zochitika zovuta pazachipatala ndikukambirana za mphamvu zawo ndi zofooka zawo mu 2003. akuphonya, ndi zolakwika zokhazikika komanso zobisika. Kuphatikiza apo, mawu akuti "zoyipa" amaphatikizanso mawu omwe nthawi zambiri amatanthauza kuvulaza odwala, monga kuvulala kwachipatala ndi kuvulala kwa iatrogenic. Chokhacho chomwe chatsalira ndikusankha ngati bungwe lowunikira ndilo bungwe loyenera kuthana ndi kulekanitsa kwa zochitika zolephereka komanso zosalephereka.
Chochitika cha alonda ndizochitika pomwe kulengeza ku Joint Commission kumafunika. The Joint Commission ikunena kuti chochitika cha alonda ndi chochitika chosayembekezereka chomwe chimaphatikizapo kuvulala kwakukulu m'thupi kapena m'maganizo. ("Sentinel Events," 2004, p.35) Palibe chosankha, chifukwa chiyenera kulembedwa. Zipatala zambiri, komabe, zimasunga zolemba zawo zofotokoza zochitika za alonda ndi zomwe angachite ngati wina atatsimikizira kuti mfundo za Joint Commission zikukwaniritsidwa. Izi ndi zina mwazochitika pamene kuli bwino kukhala otetezeka kusiyana ndi chisoni. Popeza kuti “zowopsa” ndi lingaliro lachibale, pangakhale mpata wokangana potetezera wantchito mnzathu kapena bwana. Kumbali ina, kunena molakwika chochitika cha alonda ndikwabwino kuposa kulephera kupereka lipoti la alonda. Kulephera kuulula kumatha kukhala ndi zotsatirapo zoyipa, kuphatikiza kuchotsedwa ntchito.
Poganizira zolakwika zachipatala, anthu nthawi zambiri amalakwitsa pongoyang'ana zolakwika zomwe amapatsidwa ndi dokotala. Zolakwika zamankhwala mosakayikira zimachitika pafupipafupi ndipo zimaphatikizapo zolakwika zambiri zamachitidwe monga zolakwika zina zamankhwala. Kusokonekera kwa kulumikizana, zolakwika zomwe zimachitika panthawi yamankhwala kapena kupereka, ndi zina zambiri ndizotheka. Koma tingakhale tikulingalira molakwa kwambiri nkhaniyi ngati tingaganize kuti kulakwa kwa mankhwala ndi kumene kumavulaza wodwala. Vuto limodzi lalikulu pakuyika zolakwika zosiyanasiyana zachipatala ndikusankha kuyika zolakwikazo potengera njira yomwe ikukhudzidwa kapena zotsatira zake. Ndizovomerezeka kuyang'ana maguluwa pano, poyesa kuyesa kangapo kuti akhazikitse matanthauzidwe ogwirira ntchito omwe amaphatikiza zonse zomwe zikuchitika komanso zotsatira zake, zambiri zomwe zidachokera ku ntchito ya Lucian Leape kuyambira m'ma 1990.
Limbikitsani Moyo Wanu Masiku Ano- Kanema
Kusanthula & Kupewa Zolakwa Zachipatala
Ogwira ntchito ndi osagwira ntchito anali magulu awiri akuluakulu a zochitika zovuta zomwe Leape ndi anzake adazisiyanitsa mu phunziroli. (Leape et al., 1991) Mavuto okhudza opaleshoni anali monga matenda a zilonda, kulephera kwa maopaleshoni, mavuto omwe si aukadaulo, zovuta mochedwa, ndi zovuta zaukadaulo. Osagwira ntchito: mitu monga yokhudzana ndi mankhwala, osadziwika bwino, ozunzidwa, okhudzana ndi ndondomeko, kugwa, fracture, postpartum, anesthesia-related, neonatal, and catch-all head of the system anaphatikizidwa pansi pa gulu ili la zochitika zovuta. Leape adayikanso zolakwika powonetsa zomwe zidawonongeka. Adazigawanso izi m'mitu isanu, yomwe ili:
- System
- Magwiridwe
- Mankhwala Osokoneza Bongo
- matenda
- Zoteteza
Zolakwika zambiri zamachitidwe zimagwera pamitu yopitilira imodzi, komabe zonse zimathandiza kudziwa chomwe chimayambitsa vuto. Ngati madokotala oposa mmodzi akugwira ntchito kuti adziwe malo enieni omwe akufunika kuwongolera, ndiye kuti mafunso owonjezera angafunikire.
Mwaukadaulo, cholakwika chachipatala chingapangidwe ndi wogwira ntchito aliyense pachipatala. Sizimangoperekedwa kwa akatswiri azachipatala monga madokotala ndi anamwino. Woyang'anira akhoza kumasula chitseko, kapena wogwira ntchito yoyeretsa akhoza kusiya mankhwala m'manja mwa mwana. Chofunika kwambiri kuposa kudziwitsidwa kwa wolakwayo ndi chifukwa chake. Nanga zisanachitike? Ndipo tingatsimikize bwanji kuti zimenezo sizichitikanso? Pambuyo kusonkhanitsa deta onse pamwamba ndi zina zambiri, ndi nthawi kudziwa mmene kupewa zolakwa zofanana. Ponena za zochitika za alonda, Joint Commission yalamula kuyambira 1997 kuti zonsezi zichitike ndondomeko yotchedwa Root Cause Analysis (RCA). Komabe, kugwiritsa ntchito njirayi pazochitika zomwe ziyenera kufotokozedwa kwa anthu akunja ziyenera kukonzedwa.
Kodi Choyambitsa Choyambitsa Ndi Chiyani?
Ma RCA "anajambula tsatanetsatane komanso momwe amawonera." Amapangitsa machitidwe owunikira kukhala osavuta, kuwunika ngati kuwongolera kuli kofunikira, ndikutsata zomwe zikuchitika. (Williams, 2001) Kodi RCA ndi chiyani kwenikweni? Poyang'ana zochitika zomwe zidayambitsa cholakwikacho, RCA imatha kuyang'ana kwambiri zochitika ndi njira m'malo mowunikiranso kapena kuimba mlandu anthu ena. (AHRQ, 2017) Ichi ndichifukwa chake ndikofunikira kwambiri. RCA nthawi zambiri imagwiritsa ntchito chida chotchedwa Five Whys. Iyi ndi njira yodzifunsa mosalekeza kuti "chifukwa chiyani" mutakhulupirira kuti mwazindikira chomwe chayambitsa vuto.
Chifukwa chomwe chimatchedwa "zifukwa zisanu" ndichifukwa, ngakhale zisanu ndizoyambira zabwino kwambiri, muyenera kumafunsa nthawi zonse mpaka mutazindikira chomwe chayambitsa vutoli. Kufunsa chifukwa chake mobwerezabwereza kumatha kuwulula zolakwika zambiri pamagawo osiyanasiyana, koma muyenera kupitiliza kufunsa chifukwa chake pagawo lililonse la nkhaniyo mpaka mutatha zinthu zina zomwe zingasinthidwe kuti mupereke zotsatira zabwino. Komabe, zida zosiyanasiyana kupatula izi zitha kugwiritsidwa ntchito pakufufuza zomwe zimayambitsa. Ambiri alipo. Ma RCA akuyenera kukhala amitundu yambiri komanso osasinthasintha ndikuphatikiza onse omwe akhudzidwa ndi vutolo kuti apewe kusamvetsetsana kapena kupereka lipoti lolakwika la zomwe zachitika.
Kutsiliza
Zolakwika zachipatala m'mabungwe azachipatala ndizochitika pafupipafupi komanso zosafotokozeredwa zomwe zimawopseza kwambiri thanzi la odwala. Anthu pafupifupi kotala la miliyoni amaganiziridwa kuti amamwalira chaka chilichonse chifukwa cha zovuta zachipatala. Ziwerengerozi ndizosavomerezeka panthawi yomwe chitetezo cha odwala chikuyenera kukhala chofunikira kwambiri, koma palibe zambiri zomwe zikuchitika kuti asinthe machitidwe. Ngati zolakwa zachipatala zafotokozedwa molondola ndipo gwero la vutolo likupezeka popanda kupereka mlandu kwa ogwira ntchito enieni, izi sizofunikira. Zosintha zofunikira zitha kupangidwa ngati zoyambitsa zolakwika za dongosolo kapena ndondomeko zizindikirika bwino. Njira yosasinthika, yosiyana siyana yowunikira zifukwa zomwe zimagwiritsa ntchito zikhazikiko monga zifukwa zisanu kuti zifufuze mpaka zovuta zonse ndi zolakwika zitawululidwa ndi chida chothandiza. Ngakhale kuli kofunikira kuti pakhale zochitika za alonda, Root Cause Analysis ikhoza kugwiritsidwa ntchito pazolakwitsa zonse, kuphatikizapo kuphonya pafupi.
Zothandizira
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2016). Kusanthula Zoyambitsa Mizu. Zabwezedwa pa Marichi 20, 2017, kuchokera psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/root-cause-analysis
Grober, ED, & Bohnen, JM (2005). Kufotokozera zolakwika zachipatala. Kodi J Surg, 48(1), 39-44. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15757035
Kohn, LT, Corrigan, J., Donaldson, MS, & Institute of Medicine (US). Komiti ya Quality of Health Care ku America. (2000). Kulakwitsa ndi munthu : kupanga njira yotetezeka yaumoyo. National Academy Press. books.nap.edu/books/0309068371/html/index.html
Leape, LL, Brennan, TA, Laird, N., Lawthers, AG, Localio, AR, Barnes, BA, Hebert, L., Newhouse, JP, Weiler, PC, & Hiatt, H. (1991). The chikhalidwe cha chokhwima zochitika m'chipatala odwala. Zotsatira za Harvard Medical Practice Study II. N Engl J Med, 324(6), 377-384. doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199102073240605
Lippincott ® NursingCenter®. NursingCenter. (2004). www.nursingcenter.com/pdfjournal?AID=531210&an=00152193-200411000-00038&Journal_ID=54016&Issue_ID=531132
Martinez, W., Lehmann, LS, Hu, YY, Desai, SP, & Shapiro, J. (2017). Njira Zozindikiritsira ndi Kuwunikanso Zochitika Zoyipa ndi Zosowa Zapafupi Pachipatala Chachipatala. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf, 43(1), 5-15. doi.org/10.1016/j.jcjq.2016.11.001
Patient Safety Network. (2016). Zochitika zoyipa, zophonya pafupi, ndi zolakwika. Zabwezedwa pa Marichi 20, 2017, kuchokera psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/adverse-events-near-misses-and-errors
Williams, PM (2001). Njira zowunikira zomwe zimayambitsa. Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent), 14(2), 154-157. doi.org/10.1080/08998280.2001.11927753